Publication details

Výhody a nevýhody laické participace v soudnictví

Investor logo
Title in English Advantages and Disadvantages of Lay Participation in Judiciary
Authors

BOHÁČEK Milan

Year of publication 2014
Type Article in Periodical
Magazine / Source Časopis pro právní vědu a praxi
MU Faculty or unit

Faculty of Law

Citation
Web http://www.law.muni.cz/dokumenty/28166
Field Law sciences
Keywords judiciary; lay participation; lay judge
Attached files
Description Lay participation in judicial decision-making is still a topical issue in the Czech Republic, especially due to the recent effort of the Ministry of Justice to limit the scope of participation of lay judges in court proceedings. Therefore, the author analyzes this topic in terms of reasons for the existence of lay participation in the current legislation. In addition, he defines methodology enabling him to separate the essential or primary reasons for the existence of lay participation in judicial decision-making, which themselves are capable of making the legislature introduce lay participation in the legal system, from its advantages and disadvantages. These advantages and disadvantages of lay participation are considered secondary arguments, generated by the implementation of the primary reasons, and as such they are unable to influence the decisions on codification and repeal of the institutes of lay participation. The classification, which is exemplified by jurors and justices of the peace in common law countries and lay judges in the context of the Czech Republic, is further complemented with possible reasons against the introduction of the institutes of lay participation in a legal system. Hence, in order to decide on the future form of the Czech institute of lay judges, it is particularly necessary to take into account the reasons for its existence and to start a thorough nationwide debate, the output of which should be a properly-articulated standpoint allowing for all the aspects of the discussed topic, if possible.
Related projects:

You are running an old browser version. We recommend updating your browser to its latest version.

More info